Friday, 20 November 2026

The Ecstasy of Influence: Nonfictions, Etc. By Jonathan Lethem

The Ecstasy of Influence: Nonfictions, Etc. 

By Jonathan Lethem

(Jonathan Cape, £20 stg, H/B)

Jonathan Lethem is a 48-year-old American novelist and short story writer, who began his career mixing the science fiction and detective genres, and has latterly achieved more mainstream success with novels such as Motherless Brooklyn (1999), The Fortress of Solitude (2003), You Don't Love Me Yet (2007) and Chronic City (2009). The Ecstasy of Influence is a collection of his essays, journalism and reviews. However, unlike many books of this kind, it is not just a ragbag thrown together when a writer’s cuttings drawer gets too full, but also sporadically follows the trajectory of an argument about contemporary life and culture, even if the main cohesive force or binding agent is the author’s sensibility itself. 

He sets out his stall in the Preface: ‘This preface, the title essay, and several of the newer ones (“Against ‘Pop’ Culture,” “White Elephant and Termite Postures,” “Advertisements for Norman Mailer,” “Postmodernism as Liberty Valance,” “My Disappointment Critic/On Bad Faith,” “Rushmore Versus Abundance,” and some of the interstitial remarks) makes a sporadic argument about the contemporary intellectual situation for fiction’s writers and readers, but with implications, I hope for other kinds of public thinking and talking. They’re more tendentious than the rest. If you’re in no mood to see me skirmish with injustices less ultimately urgent than hunger, disease, and discrimination you might just want to skip them. (Now he tells us.) There’s plenty else.’ Personally, I don’t find them tendentious at all, but rather the key to that ‘plenty else’. He’s also smart and humble enough to acknowledge that the fact of his being a published novelist means that what for most other people would wind up on blogs gets to reside between hard covers issued by a major corporate publisher.

“Postmodernism as Liberty Valance” has the air of a manifesto. Essentially it argues that no one can define what postmodernism is because PoMo has lots of different, sometimes incompatible characteristics, and so is all things to all people. ‘You can’t, just for instance, exalt disreputable genres like the crime story and want to do away with narrative.’ (Er, sorry to nitpick Jonathan, but Paul Auster, a fellow Brooklynite conspicuous by his absence from these pages, does just that.)

Lethem sketches out three main areas that have all been labelled ‘postmodern’, but which he believes are entirely different things, requiring different names. The first is our sense ‘…that the world defined by the advent of global techno-capitalism’ is not ‘a coherent or congenial home for human psyches.’ He denominates this Kaczynski’s Bad Dream, after the Unabomber. The second substitute term he offers ‘is for the avowed, self-declared postmodernist school of U.S. fiction writers: Robert Coover, John Barth, Donald Barthelme…Pynchon.’ These guys he calls ‘Those Guys’. Lastly, we have ‘…the postmodernism consisting simply of what aesthetic means and opportunities modernism and an ascendant popular culture left in their wake (or not their wake, since both, or at least popular culture, are still around).’ Lethem calls this third principle, for the sake of his allegory, ‘Liberty Valance’, ingeniously imagining this much vilified artistic modus operandi as Lee Marvin's amoral, brutalising character in John Ford’s 1962 film The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, who everyone thinks is shot by Jimmy Stewart (representing every orderly ‘realist’ writer from Raymond Carver to Jonathan Franzen), with the critic as John Wayne’s hidden, real assassin.

Yet, avers Lethem, ‘The persistence of the ritual disproves the ostensible result: Liberty Valance is shot, but never dies’, the reason being that ‘…postmodernism isn’t the figure in the black hat standing out in the street squaring off against the earnest and law-abiding ‘realist' novel’. Rather, ‘Postmodernism is the street. Postmodernism is the town. It’s where we live, the result of the effects of Liberty Valance’s stubborn versatility and appeal, and the fact of Kaczynski’s Bad Dream.’ But never fear, because ‘…Liberty Valance and Kaczynski’s Bad Dream aren’t the same “postmodernism.” The freedom and persuasiveness of the full array of contemporary stances and practices available to the literary artist aren’t something to renounce even if the Full Now makes us anxious to the verge of nervous breakdown. At its best, one is a tool for surviving the other – the most advanced radiation suit yet devised for wandering into the toxic future.’ It’s an exemplary piece, a high-wire juggling act where all the balls are kept spinning perfectly.

The title essay, which cocks a snook at Harold Bloom’s ‘The Anxiety of Influence’, argues for the virtues of plagiarism. I looked askance when I recognised that Lethem had ripped an anecdote almost verbatim from the late David Foster Wallace’s essay ‘E Unibus Pluram: Television and U.S. Fiction’, and was ready to adjudge it a step too far. But he had me fooled, as it turns out the entire piece is a patchwork of quotations, all of which are credited at the end. His practice demonstrates his theory, in a feat of imitative form. Odd, though, that he doesn’t mention Kathy Acker, who based her own writing on an extension of Burroughs’ cut-up method which she called plagiarism. (Incidentally, Lethem now does Wallace’s old job at Pomona College, California.)

‘My Disappointment Critic’ is a response to critic James Wood’s unfavourable review of The Fortress of Solitude. While Lethem previously regarded Wood as ‘the most apparently gifted close reader of our time’, he now marks him as ‘an unpersuasive critic whose air of erudite amplitude veiled – barely – a punitive parochialism.’ His skewering of Wood’s strictures, viz: ‘We never see him (the book’s protagonist) thinking an abstract thought, or reading a book…or thinking about God and the meaning of life, or growing up in any of the conventional mental ways of the teenage Bildungsroman’, are brilliantly lacerating. On ‘God’, for example: ‘As for “thinking about God,” was there ever a more naked instance of a critic yearning for a book other than that on his desk? Can Wood’s own negative capability not reach the possibility that in some life dramas “God” never made it to the audition, let alone failed to get onstage? Pity me if you like, but I can’t remember even considering believing in either God or Santa Claus. The debunking was accomplished pre-emptively, preconsciously. Hence, not a subject in my Bildungsroman. Sorry!’ 

Elsewhere, the ‘plenty else’ consists of autobiography and literary gossip – financial aid case Lethem, the son of bohemian hippy parents, was a contemporary of Bret Easton Ellis and Donna Tartt at posh Bennington College, and enjoyed tense, competitive friendships with both before falling out with them. His sense of ‘the blithe conversion of privilege into artistic fame’ alienated him, and he dropped out, hitchhiking across the U.S. to Berkeley, where he worked as a bookstore clerk for ten years, a voracious autodidact writing in his spare time. There are adulatory pieces on his formative influences, literary and non-literary: Marvel comic books, Philip K. Dick, Italo Calvino, J.G. Ballard; and less well-known novelists, mostly American, like Paula Fox, Thomas Berger, Shirley Jackson and L.J. Davis, plus the Chilean exile Robert Bolano. He also writes about music (there are profile/interviews of James Brown and Bob Dylan), sometimes irritatingly subjectively. The fact of his being a mid-’60s kid, reaching musical awareness in the ’80s, leads him to some of the more arcane corners of the Dylan and Stones back catalogues: Under The Red Sky or Emotional Rescue as underrated, anyone? However, my single favourite piece in the book is probably ‘The Fly in the Ointment’, a brilliant meditation on singing in the post-Elvis rock and soul era, where the vocal performance became more idiosyncratic, striving to unearth something the song itself never quite could, rather than obey the pre-rock Sinatra standard of how perfectly the lyric is served. 

Since his elevation, Lethem has become a kind of anti-Pynchon in terms of gregariousness vs. reclusiveness, hitting the conference and book tour circuit with gusto. In this regard he is emulating another of his unlikely enthusiasms, Norman Mailer. Indeed, Lethem tells us that he toyed with the idea of calling this collection Advertisements for Norman Mailer, in homage to the title of that Brooklynite forebear’s collected non-fiction, Advertisements For Myself. The self-aggrandising dangers of such excessive garrulousness are obvious. But the best critical pieces here are a valuable addition to, and elucidation of, his own enjoyable fiction.


First published in The Sunday Independent.




Thursday, 1 October 2026

Tenderwire By Claire Kilroy

Tenderwire

By Claire Kilroy

(Faber & Faber, £10.99, Jacketed Paperback Original)

This sophomore effort from Claire Kilroy is in the same genre as her much-lauded debut, All Summer, that of the literary thriller. It is a less-travelled by-road of contemporary writerly production she seems to be making her own.

The plot – and this is nothing if not a well-plotted story – concerns a young Irish concert violinist living and working in New York, Eva Tyne, with a background perhaps not unlike that of the author: hill of Howth born and bred, privileged, well-connected. Eva collapses after her solo debut and is rushed to hospital, with what subsequently transpires to have been a miscarriage. Still dazed after the incident, she goes off the rails and on a bit of a tear. Leaving her steady boyfriend, Czech photographer Krystof, she takes up with a mysterious young man she meets in a hotel bar, Peruvian investment banker Daniel. In the course of a bar-hopping night with best friend Valentina, she encounters Russian émigré Alexander – well, she thinks he’s Russian, although his provenance turns out to be as dubious as the Stradivarius violin he offers to sell her at the knock-down price of $650,000, roughly half its market value.  

After playing the violin in a drunkenly bedraggled state in the middle of the night in Alexander’s less than salubrious Brooklyn apartment, and deciding that while it may not actually be a Strad, it is certainly a very beautiful instrument, Eva becomes obsessed with raising the cash to acquire it, an undertaking she must fulfil in one week. Using a variety of sources of finance – her inheritance from her father, who disappeared in suspicious circumstances seven years ago when she was sixteen, and has just recently been declared legally deceased; revenue from the sale of her current violin; an investment loan from Daniel; – she succeeds in getting her hands on the marvellous machine, which she christens the Magdalena, she is sure will be the making of her. But, needless to say, her troubles have only just begun… 

This novel is very good on conveying the sense of money as an almost abstract, quasi-metaphysical concept which nonetheless has remorselessly real and practical implications on peoples’ lives, and the horizons within which they are allowed to live them, the expectations they are allowed, or allow themselves, to have. Eva wants to buy a violin for much more than most people spend on their home. But she hardly thinks twice about doing so, partially perhaps because of the background from which she comes. Her father, after all, was pictured on a yacht with the Taoiseach before he vanished, and ‘could’ve had an offshore account in a false name’ since ‘Everyone else did on the hill.’

Kilroy is also very good on doing minor characters. Estelle, the old woman who lives across from Eva and Krystof’s erstwhile apartment; Patrice, who manages the launderette downstairs from Daniel’s; even big, burly Alexander himself, are all brought vividly to life in a series of telling ticks. Eva’s dependence on an inhaler, being asthmatic, is also a nice detail, well used, and her references to ambient trance grooves as ‘…hollow…empty and cynical…the opposite of music’ certainly served to get me on her side.

However, as so often occurs with painstakingly plotted thrillers, the psychological depth of the central characters remains embarrassingly thin. Daniel, Krystof, Valentina, all remain ciphers on the periphery of Eva’s self-obsession and near-paranoiac jealousy, with little in the way of motivations of their own. Eva herself is, of course, wilful and manipulative, but has only a sole moment of self-conscious insight, strikingly enough in relation to her father’s shady business dealings: ‘If he was anywhere near as crooked as his only child, it would have been no bother to him. Lying, cheating, dissembling, just to get what you want. I didn’t lick it off the stones.’ True, her father’s abrupt leave-taking, and her latterly revealed miscarriage, are offered as reasons for her fugue state, but somehow neither managed to convince this reader. There again, maybe that’s because I’m a mere man. But, given her outrageously selfish behaviour, and despite her undoubted talent, while we might kind of like her, would we want to get to know her? It is doubtful if many men would want to put up with her as a girlfriend, and more doubtful still that ‘she’s worth it’.

Finally, while this is a tautly constructed thriller, there are still a few red herrings thrown around and loose ends left hanging. The supposedly significant looks given Eva by an aged Hungarian Maestro in Cologne, and his subsequent death, never amount to anything in the context of the Magdalena, and we also never find out what actually happened to her father. But life can be similarly free of ‘closure’ too, sometimes.    

So, this is a pacy, compelling, well-written concoction. Kilroy knows the moves and can pull the strings to keep an audience on tenterhooks. It will certainly keep you turning the pages deep into the night, just to find out how the story resolves itself. But, rather like a one night stand, while the adrenaline rush is exciting while it is happening, you might just feel a little bit cheated on the morning after, depending on what expectations, if any, were raised (or you thought were raised) while it was going on.

First published in The Sunday Independent



Wednesday, 9 September 2026

The Collected Stories of Benedict Kiely By Benedict Kiely

The Collected Stories of Benedict Kiely

By Benedict Kiely

(Methuen, £19.99)

As one of only five artists and writers currently honoured with election as a Saoi of Aosdana, Benedict Kiely’s reputation as one of Ireland’s grand old men of letters is nothing if not secure. However, as Colum McCann points out in his eloquent and laudatory introduction to this volume, ‘...a perverse monism sometimes remains, insisting that Kiely can be read if you’re white, Irish and over fifty. The truth is, of course, that Kiely should be read in Brixton, Mississippi, Neilstown, Johannesburg and points in between.’

As Kiely is now 81, it is timely that Metheun should gather together his four collections of short stories, and reissue them in one book. Thus we have here the entire contents of A Journey to the Seven Streams (1963), and A Ball of Malt and Madame Butterfly (1973), A Cow in the House (1978), and A Letter to Peachtree (1987), plus the 1977 novella Proxopera for good measure. 

While some of Kiely’s early stories do have a traditional structure, and follow realist patterns established by O’Connor, O’Flaherty and O’Faolain, for the most part his style is discursive and digressive, and could even be termed expressionist, in that he subordinates realism to inner vision. Sometimes the seemingly arbitrary intertwining of incidents, tales, snippets of conversation and fragments of memory can irritate, but more often than not the stories repay repeated readings, as the layers of narration are stripped back and revealed as the ebb and flow of a writer who likes travelling hopefully as much as he likes arriving. For Kiely is a master of technique, and therefore has full licence to play with conventional notions of beginning, middle and end. We trust Picasso’s Cubism because we know he can draw like Ingres, and what is fascinating about Kiely is the fluid mix of tradition with experimentation.

Like his younger advocate McCann, Kiely also transposes the national with the international, either through featuring the Irish abroad, or else people from unlikely corners of the globe washed up on these shores. So ‘A Ball of Malt and Madame Butterfly’ concerns a Japanese prostitute in Dublin, while ‘The White Wild Bronco’ could be described as Ireland’s first Wild West short story. Though written in the third person, ‘Through the Fields in Gloves’ has all the verbal tics of the central character, an old man who spray-paints young girls, while his wife sits at home, too fat to rise from her chair.

But it is the inclusion of Proxopera here that is the clincher. Weirdly prescient of the horrible events of August 15, 1998 in Kiely’s hometown of Omagh, it oscillates effortlessly between the first and third person in recounting the story of a retired schoolteacher forced by terrorists to run a proxy bomb into his local town. Far from hitching a ride on the coattails of yesterday’s headlines, this great anti-war fable should have been read, and should still be read, as a terrible warning. A flawless piece of writing, it is one more reason to celebrate this book.


First published in the Irish Independent






Wednesday, 2 September 2026

Pacazo By Roy Kesey

Pacazo 

By Roy Kesey

(Jonathan Cape, £12.99 stg, H/B)

A pacazo is ‘an uncommonly large iguana, native to the environs of Piura, NW Peru’. John Segovia is an uncommonly large, 35-year-old Californian historian living in Piura, NW Peru. It is 1997, and he went there four years ago for his doctoral research on Peruvian history, and the horrors of the conquistadors – there is a vague family myth that he might be descended from a settler with whom he shares a name – but has not yet completed. Something of an eternal postgrad slacker, he instead teaches English language at the town’s university, his position there more tenuous than tenured, his visa status problematic. Given his bulk, and apparent ugliness, he identifies with the titular reptile. However, as the word can also define ‘a petty, bitter, local god who hates fat pale pillaging strangers’, he is also repelled by it – not least because in his first year on campus one defecated on his head from the branch of a tree he was walking under on his way to work, and it took weeks before he smelled good enough again for his students to approach him. So, self-loathing is much in the air.

He has bigger problems, however, and greater reasons to hate himself. Ten months previously, his young wife, Pilar, has been raped, beaten and left for dead in the desert, dying of heatstroke later after wandering in the wrong direction. Segovia blames himself. So do his in-laws. And so he is left to care for their infant daughter, Mariangel, who was only four weeks old when the murder took place.   

The local police, venal and corrupt, have given up on the case, and so Segovia searches obsessively for clues and for his suspected perpetrator, a taxi driver. In his time off, he scours the desert where Pilar’s body was found, accumulating dubious ‘evidence’. Otherwise, he visits prostitute ‘Jenny’ occasionally, and gets into trouble continually picking on the wrong people in the street, dark young men he mistakes for the culprit.

When the floods of El Nino arrive, destroying his horde, it seems like a sign that it is time to move on. He begins socialising with his university colleagues again, even finding a new love in Karina. Then, when another woman who resembles his deceased wife is found raped and murdered in similar circumstances, and then two more, he goes into full maniacal mode again, even to the point of indulging in an episode of bodysnatching. The dénouement is disturbing, but not altogether surprising.

Written in the present tense, foremost among Kesey’s stylistic ticks are unsignposted time shifts between Segovia’s current surroundings and scenes from Peruvian history, usually occurring mid-sentence. This imbues the prose with a dream-like quality, but also casts Segovia as an unreliable narrator. So lost is he in his interior thoughts and reflections, he doesn’t always see clearly what is going on around him. In general, the writing is beautifully cadenced, recalling the arresting simplicity of William Carlos Williams. The novel is also good on depicting academic disillusionment (but under the weight of such personal tragedy, what field of professional endeavour would not appear somewhat vacuous?), and the quotidian hassles of expatriate life.

 Pacazo is Kesey’s first full-length novel, after a novella, Nothing In The World, a short story collection, All Over, and a travel guide to the Chinese city of Nanjing. At over 500 pages, it is longer than it needs to be, suggesting that maybe shorter forms suit him better. The repeated scenes of checking taxi license plates, and missing intercity buses, tend to tire fourth time around. Also, having set the story up with a noirish element, it does seem like cheating the reader to suspend the ‘investigation’ plot for most of the book. But, then again, given the quality of the writing, it would be a brave editor who would decide what to leave out. 

Besides, Pacazo isn’t really a whodunit at all. It is a study of overpowering grief, remorse and anger, and incidentally the bemusements of first-time fatherhood. On those terms, it deserves to be read, even if it does wear out its welcome.

First published in The Sunday Independent




Tuesday, 25 August 2026

The Blue Book By A. L. Kennedy

The Blue Book

By A. L. Kennedy

As regular readers of this page will be aware, I am an A. L. Kennedy fan, having already given overwhelmingly positive notices to her two preceding novels, 2004's Paradise and 2007's Day.

Writing as someone who has read all of this Scottish writer’s previous novels and short-story collections, and been an avid promoter of and enthusiastic proselytiser for them, sometimes to the point of heroine-worshipping partisanship, it gives no pleasure to opine that The Blue Book is, by a long way, the weakest fiction in an otherwise dazzling oeuvre.

The plot is simple, verging on trite: a middle-aged woman goes on a transatlantic cruise with her attentive boyfriend, meets a roguish ex-lover en voyage, and leaves her boyfriend for her ex. The woman is Elizabeth Caroline Barber, the boyfriend is plain old Derek, and the ex is Arthur Peter Lockwood. Elizabeth, formerly Beth, is temporarily fleeing the UK, in flight from her past, which mostly means the life she shared with the charismatic Arthur, when she partnered him in touring church halls as mediums, perfecting the arcane but also practical skills utilised by believable frauds in facilitating the bereft and bereaved to contact their deceased loved ones on “the other side”. When Elizabeth finally rejected what once seemed an intoxicating game as merely an unpardonable series of tawdry crimes, Arthur continued his search for the right way to do wrong, or to do the wrong thing for the right reasons. He now subsidises free closure for the traumatised and dispossessed (e.g. Agathe in Montreal, a survivor of Rwandan ethnic cleansing, while her husband and son were not) by preying on the super-rich (e.g. Peri Arpagian in New York, a widow still missing her passed-on, self-made mining industrialist and environmental polluting husband, Mels), and does very well for himself too, into the bargain. Elizabeth and Arthur still met occasionally, for weekends of sexual oblivion, but their desperate affection lacerated as much as it consoled. Thus, poor Derek, who is “perfectly adequate”, and may be planning to propose marriage, but spends most of the crossing in bed with seasickness, not helped by the fact that after Elizabeth encounters Arthur she starts substituting anodyne but ineffective medication for his seasick tablets.

So, why doesn’t it work? All the usual stylistic ticks and familiar techniques are present and correct: the italics to indicate interior monologue and/or sarcastically toned stream of consciousness; the bold type for emphasis within those excursions; the short, sometimes one-sentence, sometimes even one-word paragraphs; the rhetorical repetitions. These have proved invaluable resources before, but such devices have grown over-familiar through overuse, and should perhaps be pressed into action more sparingly. As it is, they are beginning both to look and sound like emotional incontinence, a literary running off at the mouth, or mind. Of course, it can be argued that this modus operandi provides an accurate representation in prose of Elizabeth’s thought processes and how she feels, an appropriate matching of style to content, but the close juxtapositioning of reams of lazy, loose writing with wonderfully arresting insights wrapped in poetic phrasing is highly frustrating. Kennedy fails to, ahem, strike a happy medium. There is also the fact that Elizabeth’s situation doesn’t seem to warrant such neurotic flights.

The downgrading of Derek from harmless stooge to petulant control freak is convenient but contrived, and ultimately self-serving. The sporadic direct addressing of the reader in the second person singular, as a performer would an audience, is far from innovative, featuring prominently as it did in Jay McInerney's 1984 novel Bright Lights, Big City, and is a staple of postmodern fiction, for example Italo Calvino's 1979 masterpiece, If On A Winter’s Night A Traveller. Besides which, the “you” addressed switches willy-nilly between being the reader and Elizabeth talking to herself. Then, the significance of the title is never adequately explained, but it is certainly no exhaustive meditation on an area of the psychic and colour spectrum as thorough as William Gass's beautiful essay, On Being Blue. Or maybe it’s because Hilary Mantel gave us a much more substantial and satisfying exploration of the hocus-pocus thing in 2005’s Beyond Black, perhaps because it paid more attention to social context than Kennedy chooses to do here. Finally, there is the “tragic revelation” at the end which is supposed to explain everything (and why do I feel the need to resort to that unpardonable mannerism of both writing style and speech pattern, the inverted commas or finger-flexing, when reviewing this book?), but which instead feels woefully tacked on and, as the youthful Martin Amis would have put it, “real dead babies”. In short, the whole book is a series of unlikely occurrences and outlandish situations which, as they say, “fail to convince”.

Granted, this pulling a rabbit out of a hat, narratively speaking, is meant to mimic a magic, or a confidence, trick. But there are few things more embarrassing to watch than a conjuror, or a conman, who doesn’t pull it off. I didn’t “believe” a word of it, and that is what makes this latest piece of sleight of hand, by the gifted illusionist A. L. Kennedy, her first serious misstep.

First published in The Sunday Independent.




Friday, 7 August 2026

Paradise By A.L. Kennedy

Paradise 

By A.L. Kennedy

Hannah Luckraft drinks too much. She’s been drinking too much since she was seventeen, and now she’s pushing forty, with nothing much to show for it: ‘Because I was born with the absolute certainty that I would die before leaving thirty. I arrived with ten toes and blue eyes and death firmly in mind. I passed the age when lives should be taken in hand, knowing that no such formalities would be required. For me, there would be no pension, no insurance, no prudent mortgage plan, no fretting over outrages in homes for the elderly, or the ultimate loss of my health and faculties. I was carefree. And completely wrong, of course.’ There is also no child, which in her ‘personal arithmetic’ means ‘Hannah Luckraft = Nothing’.

Hannah, whose nomenclature manages to combine both the idea of grace and religious longing in its ‘Christian’ first part with the trusting to blind fate (rather than faith) of someone all at sea in treacherous waters in its Family second half, will drink anything she can get her hands on, including the ever reliable old standby from schooldays, cough mixtures, although she’s not too keen on lager. Her favourite is: ‘Bushmill’s, County Antrim, 700 millilitres, 40 per cent. I mean, what else do you need to know? Not that, as an additional courtesy, you don’t turn it in your hands and love the rounded corners and the dapper weight and the elegant cut of the label: the black with the white and the gold, all shaped around each other to mark out an arch: a long, slim doorway to somewhere else. And God bless the rectangular bottle, for it will not roll and harm itself.’ She regularly has blackouts, waking up without a clue where she is, only to recollect later that – to take a random example – she spent a portion of the previous evening giving a vigorous blowjob to the unattractive total stranger she now finds herself chatting to across a hotel breakfast table. 

Fans of the quick-fix quackery dignified under the term ‘psychiatry’, or the more long drawn-out charlatanism which passes itself off as ‘therapy’, will search in vain for THE REASON Hannah behaves in this punishingly self-destructive way. Her childhood has been comfortable and stable, in fact a lot less traumatic than average. She is blessed with loving, supportive and – most important of all, given her inclinations – forgiving parents. Then there’s her doctor brother, Simon, whose social and material success may be a standing reproach to Hannah (who is, ridiculously, ‘something in cardboard’, that is until she gets the sack and starts working in a bar) and who, while he may have a smug shrew for a wife and a baby on the way, still cares enough to get her into a treatment clinic in Canada, and foot the bill for it. Plus there’s Robert, her recently acquired dentist boyfriend, whom she fell for because of his ‘drinker’s smile’. Yes, he’s as big a dipsomaniac as she is, if not worse, but that doesn’t stop her being crazy about him.

Doubtless any therapist worth his inflated 50-minute-hourly fee would dub this relationship ‘co-dependent’, but our Hannah isn’t about to be taken in by any of their value-laden, socially-controlling, self-serving guff, and much satire is knocked out of her time in recovery: ‘This morning, we’re sitting in a circle again – this means we’re doing something to make us better, the kind of something that we get instead of treatment. Apparently it’s a known fact that no one has ever recuperated from any unfortunate state without being slapped down into a grisly ring of pink Naugahyde armchairs and made to discuss their personal lives with a dozen emotional vampires listening.’ Shrinks aren’t any better, in Hannah’s view, their evil bunk giving them a license to behave much worse than priests and nuns ever did: ‘Tomorrow morning, I’m supposed to go off and have my skull cracked by some consultant, let him fumble around when there’s nothing left for anyone to find. I’ve been professionally groped here for over a week: whatever thrill there was in it has gone. I’ll tell him my dream and he’ll grill me about masturbation or fetishes and then try to make me feel abnormal. This doesn’t suit people like me… We need something gentle.’  

So, why does she drink? If the standard answer is ‘To forget’, and the further routine inquiry ‘To forget what?’ is always inevitably met by the comic reply, ‘I’ve forgotten’, none of this is applicable to Hannah. For she remembers, in painful, self-lacerating detail. Indeed, it would be easy to conclude that her default setting is remorse, if it were not for the cutting, paradoxical humour with which it is leavened. Why does she drink? ‘I am delicate and the world is impossibly wrong, is unthinkable and I am not forewarned, forearmed, equipped. I cannot manage. If there was something useful I could do, I would – but there isn’t. So I drink.’ Maybe it would be better to ask a geneticist why she is the way she is; or, failing that, a philosopher. For the metaphysical ironies and moral ambiguities in Kennedy’s work are beyond most of her contemporaries, and are expressed, as they could only be, in a prose style that is virtuoso in its linguistic brilliance. If this review contains excessive quotation, it is simply because this is very definitely a case where it is better to let the writing do the talking. Kennedy thrives on paradox: Paradise is, obviously, an inferno, but it is nonetheless a paradise for all that.

Allegedly a teetotaller, Kennedy has here performed a miracle of imaginative empathy. One would have to go back over seventy years, to Djuna Barnes’s Nightwood, to find a woman writing so well about the interiority of the drinking life. As it is, this is a lyric work which bears comparison with Malcolm Lowry’s rather more epic booze hound’s bible, Under The Volcano. It ends with a supremely well-rendered surreal train journey, which turns into a sort of pilgrimage, full of happy serendipities.

There are always only a handful of gifted and important writers in the world at any particular time, writers who really matter. Already an accomplished practitioner of the short story, with three previous highly ambitious novels behind her, Paradise provides further evidence, if any more were needed, that A.L. Kennedy is among that select company. It also, incidentally, bears ongoing witness to the thoroughgoing, media-driven farce that is the Mann Booker Prize, for which this wonderful novel did not even make the long list, much less take its rightful place among the shortlisted six.

First published in The Sunday Independent




Thursday, 23 July 2026

Day By A.L. Kennedy

Day 

By A.L. Kennedy

(Jonathan Cape, £16.99 Sterling)

Alfred Day, former tail-gunner in a Lancaster bomber during WW2, is the protagonist of Alison Kennedy’s fifth novel. It is now 1949, and Alfred, only 25 but feeling more like 50, is finding he’s not very good at peace. The only boy in a family of girls, with a drunken, abusive fishmonger father and a doting and doted on mother, the war (or more specifically, the R.A.F., or more exactly still, his flying crew) offered him a previously unimagined camaraderie, and an escape from his rural Staffordshire origins and having to follow his father into his smelly trade. For all the rigid class structure of Britain, reflected in the officer class/ordinary ranks divide of the armed forces, the war was a great leveller, with everyone mucking in together. But look at him now, trying not very successfully to negotiate the readjustment to civilian life, a way of being as an adult that he has never properly known.

He has been working in his friend Ivor’s bookshop in London, although they don’t seem to sell many books. Not that he’s very bothered, since the autodidact Alfred has always been fond of reading. What’s really eating him is numbness, a sense of psychological paralysis occasioned by the loses he has accumulated: his mother, ostensibly felled by a falling roof slate, although Alfred suspects, rightly or wrongly, that his father had something to do with her demise; his crew, since he was the only survivor when his plane was shot down over Hamburg in 1943 on their penultimate 29th bombing mission; and his girlfriend Joyce, a chance encounter during the Blitz, then as now unhappily married to a lieutenant she hardly knew before he was sent off to Malaya, went missing – either dead or imprisoned – who has returned with major trauma (i.e. he never leaves their house). Then Alfred also has his experiences as a German PoW to deal with, not least of which is the death of his friend from the camp, Ringer, who saved him, but whom he failed to save.

So, when the novel opens, we discover he has volunteered as an extra in a prison-camp movie being shot in Germany, trying to find the piece of him that had come adrift in the real prison. He is surrounded by actors playing the war, new and old service men, ‘good’ Germans and displaced persons, and among them are people like him, who won’t talk about what happened. Then there are the kind of people he was fighting, like the nasty piece of work that is the Nazi collaborator Vasyl, really Latvian but claiming to be Ukrainian because he thinks this will ease his passage into British residency, whose personal (im)morality, or code of survival, is summed up succinctly in his saying: ‘It’s like this – you kiss your wife, I take away her face – which one of us is more sensible? You hold on to her hand when she can’t feel and then I stop you feeling – which one of us is more sensible? You care about your daughter – I train my dog to fuck your daughter – you still care – which one of us is more sensible?’

The film set affords the opportunity for some arch but telling postmodern irony: ‘Penalty for non-compliance, one hour in the sun with hands up. They’d be filming that next: trembling British arms and British sweat, very dramatic – lots of sympathy you’d get with that – now that it wasn’t happening any more, now that it was a story.’  Kennedy even pushes it as far as having some (real) ex-prisoners trying to tunnel out of their (fake) new camp, unbeknownst to the production crew. Some of this inner circle take Alfred under their wing, offering him a new start, with false black market identity papers and the chance to be someone else, an option Alfred gives some consideration.

The novel, then, is about the crushing weight of guilt, and the redemptive power of love. If that sounds trite, it isn’t meant to. It is also, strangely enough, given its forensic delineation of the darker propensities of human nature, perhaps Kennedy’s most optimistic longer work to date. In the end, Alfred decides to accept his lot, be himself, go back to London, and take a chance on contacting Joyce.

In these homogenised, commodified times, it is increasingly rare to find a writer with both a signature style, and a sensibility (the two are intimately linked), so distinctly their own that they are instantly recognisable upon opening one of their books, and could not be anyone else’s. A.L. Kennedy is such an artist, and Day handsomely extends her already highly impressive achievement in contemporary fiction.

First published in The Sunday Independent